My Favourite Scores – 1925

  • The Battleship Potemkin
  • Dmitri Shostakovich
  • Unreleased

Sergei Eisenstein’s silent propaganda film The Battleship Potemkin has had several scores composed for it over the years. In fact, I’ve read that the director himself wanted a score written for the film every 20 years. Back in the mid-70s Russian officialdom took sequences from several of Dmitri Shostakovich’s symphony works (Symphonies No. 4, 5, 8, 10 and 11) and fashioned a score to accompany the film for it’s 50th anniversary release.

I watched the film just recently on YouTube and it featured Shostakovich’s score and I was immediately taken by the music I heard. At the same time giving an emotional basis to the visuals, as well as hitting the on-screen action moments, the music seems almost to have been written specifically for the film because whole swathes of Shostakovich’s music hits several key moments in the movie – just as expertly as any film composition written specifically for a film today (though the film itself may have been slightly edited to fit the chosen music). My enthusiasm for the music I heard is probably down to the excellence of Shostakovich’s writing of “classical music” in general but it fits the film so well. I even spent some time going through the symphonies used to put together the score, editing out the relevant portions and putting together my own Shostakovich soundtrack. Although chopped up (I apologise to classical music purists who must be holding their hands up in horror at the thought of this!), the music still exudes power and emotion.

The sequence of the massacre on the Odessa Steps is a sequence that is always quoted as being a key scene on film history and the music chosen to accompany this sequence (first and second movements of the 11th Symphony and part of the third movement of the 5th Symphony) is a fine example of how well Shostakovich’s music works. And this is only one example, there are many more.

A closing word should go also to Edmund Meisel’s score for the film (Edelton / 1995 / 53:40). Composed for orchestra in little over 12 days in 1927 (and which supposedly helped turn the film into a major hit), Meisel’s score feels more of a “mickey-mouse” score as it seems to follow more the on-screen actions. Lost for many years, Meisel’s score was reconstructed in the mid-90s and is well worth a listen.



  1. I was under the impression that the Shostakovich score was prepared for a new print of the film to mark the 50th anniversary of the mutiny, rather than the 50th anniversary of the film, which for me raises the intriguing possibility that Shostakovich actually wrote part of what became the 11th Symphony for the film – specifically the Odessa Steps music. I’d always thought that that music would fit the Odessa Steps sequence even before I knowingly saw that print. If the print was originally prepared in 1955 – which would also account for the appallingly scratchy (optical?) soundtrack – then Shostakovich might have written the key part of the music for the film, but then put the project aside for some reason, only then to incorporate it into his wider, more general work on the 1905 Revolution, the 11th Symphony.

    I’ve searched for some time for evidence to support this theory, but found none. On the other hand, I’ve found none to disprove it either!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: